Called to Coach: Moving Beyond Circumstance and Confusion

Four years ago I completed my Masters of Arts in Ministry degree after spontaneously applying to a program I never thought I’d get into. As a 7-12 math teacher, I had gotten used to being asked the question, “So what are you going to do with it?” “It” being my ministry foundation.

Oh, how I hated that question. I wanted to respond with an exasperating cry, “I have no freaking clue!” I don’t know why God asked me to sign up for this, but He did, so here I am. Instead, I would shove that response down deep inside my chest, smile, and reply, “I don’t really know. I’m not planning on going anywhere. For right now I am simply enjoying the self-formation.” While there were definitely hints of truth in that response, I knew there was something more going on – I just didn’t know what. So, I forged ahead not knowing, marinating in constant confusion about what I was supposed to be doing with my life.

Then, last summer came, and a small voice kept pulling on my heart strings saying, “Kylie, step out of the shadows.” For so long I had hidden behind my identity as a teacher and a volleyball coach. I absorbed myself in learning, but always avoided the application. I shied away from putting myself out there in a way that would make a new kind of impact, the uncomfortable kind. I hid in my circumstances and avoided stepping outside of my cozy fuzzy blanket zone. I did this not because God wasn’t calling me to something new, but because I couldn’t see through the other side of the calling.

I knew God was on the other side of the wall of fog, but I couldn’t bring myself to step into the unknown.  I took my “free” time that summer attempting to convince myself I could be a life-coach. I struggled through building a website. I hid in frustration behind Instagram reels. I second guessed every blog post, leaving most of them untouched on my desktop never to be seen by the eyes of others. And, I even coached a few people. Yet, I would take two steps forward, and always retreat back into what was comfortable by refocusing my efforts on all things that weren’t actually coaching.

Trust in the LORD with all your heart, on your own intelligence do not rely. – Proverbs 3:5

It’s a good thing God reminds us to trust in Him and in ourselves! News flash- circumstantial identity is not a real thing. Letting that go was hard, and is a continual process, but fast forward to today and I am living with a much enhanced purpose. Through the Purgative Way course, the Ingolds and their team have given me the tools to apply all of my God-given gifts to the coaching realm that not only meshes my love for teaching and my Catholic faith, but allows me to create space for the people around me to grow.

Since starting the Purgative Way course. I have changed my approach to coaching and teaching. I have been more confident in reaching out to others, which has resulted in great fruits from the Holy Spirit. I have been able to coach my co-workers in education who are often forging ahead into the choppy waters of stress, anxiety, and overwhelm. I have restructured my thought exercises and mindset work for my high-school athletes. I have even applied the concepts of the Metanoia Catholic Journal to my conversations with my six-year old daughter.

What I have found is that I no longer get anxious before a session or in speaking truth with others. Rather, I feel at peace both entering and leaving my time with clients, as well as when I openly discuss my faith with non-clients as well.

My focus is now much more centered on what matters – leading souls to heaven. I worry less over trivial things and I am able to bounce back from self-doubt much quicker. My thoughts centered on what other people are thinking of me have significantly decreased, and I am much more aware of how I am responding to my circumstances. My story is now a helpful tool in which I can recognize where lies are at play, rather than a roadblock keeping me from spiritual and personal growth.

I am so grateful God has led me to this wonderful community of men and women who are traveling on a similar trajectory toward Christ, albeit through many different vehicles and settings. When I started the Purgative Way course,I was looking for an alternative to getting my spiritual direction certification. For one thing, I have two small children and I wasn’t mentally in a place where I felt ready to handle a heavy workload. The second barrier was the high price tag associated with the programs I had inquired about. So, I did a quick Google search and by the grace of God, Metanoia Catholic came up. I scheduled a call with Erin, prayed about it, and decided to give it a try.

If you are on the fence, I encourage you to take it to prayer and trust that your efforts will be blessed. I, for one, will be praying for you on your journey as you allow the Holy Spirit to transform you, through the renewal of your mind, and your openness to God’s call.

Canceled

“This is not what I planned! I’m going to miss out! I wish things were different!”

These were some of the many thoughts that went through my mind as I grasped to find another flight. My perfectly timed flight was canceled, and the next available flight was not until 4 days later. This meant I would be missing a good friend’s wedding. “I can’t miss this!” I thought as I scrolled through my phone to find another flight:

Canceled

Canceled

Flight Unavailable

Flight Unavailable

“If my situation would just change, I’d be happy.”

I found myself trying to change my circumstance, because I thought that would make me happy. And while it might be easier to be happy in a different circumstance, it was definitely possible for me to be happy in the place I found myself. This is because the emotion of happiness comes from a thought in my mind.

To add a cherry on top, I was on day 8 out of 9 days praying the Surrender Novena, where every day I repeated, “Oh Jesus, I surrender myself to You. Take care of everything.” Ironic? I think not. I believe the Lord was offering me a way to practice the surrender I was praying for.

So what did I do about my flight? Does surrender mean to say “I give up?” No, but rather to say the words of the Serenity Prayer: “God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference.”

When my flight was canceled I called the airline right away, but it was out of a place of haste and frustration.

God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change…

Fortunately for me, I was put on hold. It was as if the Lord was saying to me: “STOP! You are trying to write this story by yourself, but I, your God, want to be involved!” After journaling and reflecting, I became aware of the thoughts that were leading me to anxiety and was able to see that they were not benefiting me. By becoming aware of my thoughts, I had the ability to choose to think differently.

… courage to change the things I can…

By the end of the day, I tried calling again, but this time I called to know and truly understand what was happening.

… and wisdom to know the difference!

While it still seemed true that I would be missing out, I came to realize that this thought wasn’t helping me. And in fact it was harming me by complaining and getting irritated. Instead, I could focus on what I could change: my thoughts.

My flight was still canceled, and I couldn’t change that even though I tried. So, instead, I chose to focus on thoughts that would be helpful: I could live stream the wedding mass, I could spend more time with my family, the weather was clearing up and I could take a walk, I had time to catch up on phone calls with friends… This change in plans actually could be for the better! If I had spent all my time focusing on missing out, I would miss the biggest gift of all: the present time which is right in front of me!

“Depend on the Lord in whatever you do, and your plans will succeed.” Proverbs 16:3

Coming Out as Catholic: Metanoia in Action

I entered the Catholic church during the Easter Vigil on April 23, 1992, the same day as the con-validation of our civil marriage. Yes, we got married at the JP so I could get my green card, but that’s a story for another day.

So, why, at the end of 2022, do I have this mighty desire to “come out Catholic?” Didn’t the whole congregation witness my profession of faith? Wasn’t that enough? The difference is, although I meant my profession of faith the first time, I professed more with my mouth and less with my heart.

It has taken me 30 years of wrestling, of metanoia in action, to have this deep desire to proclaim publicly, “…that Jesus is Lord,” and I “believe in [my] heart that God raised Him from the dead…For with the heart one believes and is justified, and with the mouth one confesses and is saved” (Romans 10:9-10).

Over the years, I barely scratched the surface of the vast treasures of Scripture and Tradition as I raised my family, served in my parish and pursued a teaching career. Don’t get me wrong, I was never ashamed to say that I was Catholic in secular circles. My friends and colleagues knew, but I was elective in how I lived out my faith. It’s just not enough to simply be a “practicing Catholic in good standing” anymore.

Now, in middle age, as I pursue a new career in coaching, I’ve landed in the Metanoia Catholic, a community of seekers of Truth, Beauty and Goodness. Coming out Catholic all of a sudden takes on a different meaning as I watch Matt and Erin Ingold so boldly demonstrate their faith. I see them do what I so desperately want for myself, to be unabashedly Catholic in a world that is turning more and more against the faith. I am inspired and will be equipped to BE a Catholic Coach. God is good.

I received this poem in Adoration on August 8, 2022 on my year-long journey of discernment.

Coming Out Catholic

I’m coming out Catholic
What’s that, you ask?
I’m telling the world
Not hiding in the dark.
No shame in telling
My precious faith story
How Jesus had saved me
In all of His glory.
Finding my fire
Shouting from the spire
Dispelling the lies
In front of my eyes
Surrendering, trusting
Receiving the grace
Adoring Him now
His Eucharistic Face.
I’m coming out Catholic
I’m running the race
In trustful surrender,
I’m taking my place.

Christ is calling me into a closer relationship with Him so that I can serve others in His name. He is not calling me to serve as a Mindset Coach for Catholics, but to serve as a Catholic Mindset Coach in an ever more secularized society because, “The harvest is great, but the laborers are few” (Matthew 9: 27). I want to serve, not because my prospective clients are Catholic, but because I am. I believe I am here in the Metanoia Catholic Academy and Catholic Coaching Foundations not by chance, but because He has called me here to equip me to serve Him in a greater capacity as I receive the training and grow alongside the community of believers. It’s a beautiful thing.

So, to sum up in poetry my journey thus far I:

Unfurl the Truth
Like a banner across my heart
Letters in scarlet
There from the start
Broken and beaten
To Jesus a path
His love is greater
than this worldly treasure
A healing balm
A wondrous salve
Freedom from grasping
For temporal pleasures
I’m coming out Catholic
The journey begins
To bring God the glory
He knows how it ends.

Dating Again

Hey y’all! Mark here. I’m a Resident Coach here at Metanoia Catholic. I’m hopping on the blog today to share with you how coaching transformed my life and my marriage and offer you a special invitation.

But first, a story.

Abby, our 2 boys (& baby coming in December), and I currently live in Ave Maria, Florida, but we are originally from south Louisiana. This Easter, we drove home to visit family and spend the holiday with them. We had a great time. Not only did Abby and I knock years off our time in purgatory (please, Lord!) with roughly 40 hours in the car over 5 days with 2 small kids, but we also had the chance to stay at both of our parents’ houses. We spent 2 nights with my parents and 2 nights with Abby’s parents.

A beautiful moment occurred while staying at my folks’ house. During a lull in conversation, my dad turned to me and said, “I’ve really been enjoying my time with your mom.”

That simple sentence struck me.

A little about Mom and Dad. My parents have been married for over 50 years! Dad is 70, and Mom is 68. They were 19 and 17 years old when they got married, and now, over 50 years later, my dad is proclaiming to me how much he enjoys spending time with my mom.

What a gift!

The time they spend together has greatly increased recently due to my dad choosing to back away from extra work outside the home. My dad is the hardest working man I’ve ever known. He spent years wielding in the shipyards of south Louisiana, then he worked at a chemical plant for nearly 3 decades. Once he retired from there he got another job and then another. Those years of hard work provided for his family, and I am grateful. But those years of work also came with a price: time.

Dad shared with me some of the things he and my mom had been doing since he stepped back from working outside their home. They’ve been tackling house projects, grilling outside, sipping wine, and cooking (my mom even taught my dad how to make a roux). All of these things they have been doing together.

Upon reflecting on this, I came to realize that the things my parents are doing together are simple and very ordinary. Yet these simple things have drawn them closer together. The time they are spending with one another is impacting their marriage and you can see it. In many ways, even after 50 years, my parents started dating again.

It got me thinking about when Abby and I were dating…

I couldn’t wait to give my time to her.

Many of the ways we spent time together were simple and ordinary: we would watch a movie, have dinner, talk on the phone, etc. To be honest, it never really mattered to me what we were doing. I just wanted to be with her, and during our time together, I came to know her more and more and the connection between us grew.

Once we got married, we had even more opportunities to connect. But I noticed something odd: while our chances for connection increased, our overall connection somehow decreased. I quickly found myself reaching for the TV remote or my phone instead of engaging in meaningful conversation with my beloved bride. Where we had once experienced deep connection, distance took its place. Where I once strived to connect, I allowed myself to get comfortable and complacent.

It seemed such a strange thing to have felt more connected to my bride BEFORE she actually was my bride.

But then 3 things happened that had a profound impact on my life and my marriage: (1) Abby and I found Metanoia Catholic (thanks, Abs), (2) we began coach training, and (3) we put in the work.

Abby and I sensed the disconnection within our marriage, and we couldn’t stand it. We began investing in our marriage, and that changed everything. In many ways, like my parents, we began dating again. Now it is very common to find Abby and I up late talking for hours after the kids are asleep. We play games together. We create together. We laugh together. We work together. We dream together.

It seems my dad and I have come to the same conclusion: our brides are worth spending intentional time with. Abby is worth dating, even though we’re married.

And I’ll tell you a secret…it’s better. So much better.

Things can be better for you too. No, you don’t have to wait until the kids move out. No, you don’t have to wait until that precious summer vacation. No, you don’t have to wait until you find a babysitter. No, you don’t have to wait until you retire. No, you don’t have to wait. The time is now. Right now.

Investing in my marriage has been one of the best decisions I have ever made.

Beginning Monday, May 1, 2023, I’m launching an 8-week group coaching experience for married men and women who want to invest in their marriages called Dating Again. Through our time together, I will be sharing the same skills that helped me discover new depths in my marriage and a new way of seeing my wife.

Are you ready to invest in your marriage? Are you ready to move from distance to communion with your spouse? It’s possible. I’m living proof, and so is my dad.

What if you could reignite excitement within your marriage?

What if you could see your spouse as a gift?

What if you could develop a fruitful, consistent prayer life with your spouse?

What if you could make your relationship with your spouse priority?

I’m here to tell you, you can.

If you want to experience greater connection and intimacy within your marriage, then join me. Just imagine what your marriage could look like if you made it your priority for 8-weeks. In just 8-weeks, God can transform your life … and your marriage.

Will you join me?? Registration for Dating Again is now open!

For more information and to register, click here: https://linktr.ee/markdufrene

Attention College Students!

The enemy is working overtime to disrupt your mental health and keep you from accomplishing God’s will. The mental health crisis for college-aged youth is widely documented and the picture is concerning.

A recent survey of Americans considering higher education found that self-doubt was one of the top three barriers to enrollment, alongside ‘competing obligations and logistics’ and ‘cost.’

Ironically, self-doubt is the barrier most within students’ locus of control. When self-doubt is not addressed, it can lead students to avoid more rigorous academic programs or dissuade them from applying to graduate or professional school. Self-doubt and imposter syndrome can limit job prospects, career satisfaction, and lifelong earning potential.

Just as concerning is the number of young people who are leaving our Catholic faith.

Almost 80 percent of those who leave Catholicism do so by the age of 23. Many who leave become “nones” with no particular religious affiliation or belief in God.

As a Certified Catholic Mindset Coach and founder of Knots Untied Coaching, my aim is to help college students embrace Catholicism as an essential element to success in their educational journey. With over 30 years of teaching and advising students on college campuses, I’m very familiar with the challenges students face. As someone who was a first-generation college student, a traditional age graduate student, and a mid-life doctoral student, I help students overcome the mental taunts of the enemy and infuse virtuous living into their collegiate environment.

Our world needs more faith-filled, ambitious Catholics in leadership positions in every industry! With the infusion of AI technology into our daily lives, humans are entering a new Attention Economy.

The Attention Economy trains us to combat loneliness with scrolling, boredom with digital content, and real-world connections with disembodied virtual assistants. College-aged people are the front lines of the battlefield for our minds… but all of us are touched.

It’s so important for Catholics to focus our attention on God’s desire for us to develop healthy and holy habits and freedom through virtuous living. I care deeply about the future of our world and the futures of the young people who will lead it.

In September 2023, I will launch my first virtual collegiate success program. The 12-week “Fearful to Fruitful” workshop will help college students learn to strengthen their interior life, overcome obstacles to success, and live lives of virtue. Go to www.knots-untied.com to register. You can also follow my podcast Catholics on Campus to learn a variety of success strategies to help you live happy, healthy and holy lives.

Becoming a Student of Gratitude

I’ve been working on this poem in bed at night before falling asleep, and it’s been helpful to develop more self acceptance and self love.

Grateful

I’m grateful for my fingers.

I’m grateful for my toes.

I’m grateful for my hands and my feet and my nose.

I’m grateful for my shoulders.

I’m grateful for my shins.

I’m grateful for my ears and my eyes and my chin.

I’m grateful for my gums.

I’m grateful for my tum.

I’m grateful for my teeth and my lips and my knees.

I’m grateful for my nails.

I’m grateful for entrails.

I’m grateful for my back and my bottom and my breasts.

I’m grateful for my curls.

I’m grateful for my cheeks.

I’m grateful for my brain and the mind it contains.

I’m grateful for my ankles.

I’m grateful for my elbows.

I’m grateful for my eyebrows and my wrists and my fists.

I’m grateful for my pimples.

I’m grateful for my moles.

I’m grateful for my cranium and my spine and my dimples.

I’m grateful for my arms.

I’m grateful for my legs.

I’m grateful for my loins

Two gifts from God, Rejoice!

I’m grateful for blood.

I’m grateful for my veins.

I’m grateful for my skin and the life that’s within.

I’m grateful for my heart,

I’m grateful for my art.

I’m grateful for my sight and my touch and my sound.

I’m grateful to the Father.

I’m grateful to the Son.

I’m grateful to the Spirit.

Holy God all three in One

I’m grateful.

What are you grateful for? I would be interested in seeing what others in this community come up with!

Carron Silva Ph.D, 1/27/2023

In Response to Hannah Dustman’s 10 Day Metanoia Catholic Journal Challenge:

We challenge you, members of the Metanoia Catholic community, to commit to naming 10 things you are grateful about yourself every day for the next 10 days. Are you up for the challenge?

Being an Everyday Pilgrim

Twelve years ago, I became a pilgrim, walking nearly 500 miles across northern Spain to arrive in Santiago de Compostela via the Camino Frances. But in the 12 subsequent years, I realized that as a Catholic I have always been a pilgrim.

To be a pilgrim is to be on a journey with a specific destination in mind, usually religious in nature. To what or to whom am I headed? This question is one that we can clearly answer as Catholics – to beatitude, and to God.

That destination matters. It allows for orientation and course correction. It does not mean that the journey is meaningless – far from it – but it does mean something different than “the journey is the destination.” If I am not aimed towards where I want to be, the journey will ultimately be in vain.

In reflecting on what I am learning through Metanoia Catholic, to be a coach is to help others orient themselves towards God and beatitude. Is that not a pilgrimage? The physical distance may be short in our minds and brains and synapses, but there is movement towards God.

I embarked on that first official pilgrimage in my early 30s, feeling a bit at a crossroads. I spent six weeks walking through a country where I did not speak the language, knew no one, and had very little idea of what was coming next, guidebook notwithstanding. Twelve years later, in the fall of 2022, I felt at a similar crossroads.

Coming through the grief of losing my mother to cancer in March 2020, I was seeking consolation and grappling with some big emotions. I stumbled across this thing called Catholic Coaching and dove in. Here was another place where I did not speak the language, knew no one, and did not know what was coming next. But I heard a voice saying to me, “Let’s do something new together,” and knew that another pilgrimage called.

As I did for that first pilgrimage, I tried to gather all the information I could. With a vast array of podcasts, blog posts, lessons within the Metanoia Catholic Academy, and even a few coaching sessions, I quickly was overwhelmed, but not discouraged. With every podcast and coaching session, I found myself feeling seen and understood, and I began to feel a tug towards the path of bringing others into that same space.

If I really want to accomplish something, I need a big goal. My motto for my Camino was, “One step at a time,” while also having a big goal of walking 500 miles. With coaching, while I was still only at the early stages, it seemed that my timing was just right to join the upcoming Catholic Coaching Certification class. So I crunched some numbers, prayed for wisdom, and journaled my way into signing up. On the day of our first class, I felt the same apprehension I had the day I left for Spain 12 years ago – what have I gotten myself into?!

One of the things I have discovered in my journaling is that I have a lot of all or nothing thinking. And perhaps my pilgrimage method is a bit like that – I don’t want to just go for a walk, I want to walk across Spain; I don’t want to just be coached, I want to get certified! But something happens when you embark on a pilgrimage. You take one step in the direction of your goal. Then another. And another. Sometimes that step is on straight, even paths. Other times, it’s a hard slog up and over the Pyrenees. It’s sometimes arriving at the wrong bus stop and having to walk across a city a second time. But every day there is progress of some sort. I moved closer to my goal, even if I was hurting, or took the scenic route, or was grumpy and didn’t want to talk to anyone.

Yes, there is a conscious decision to become a pilgrim, a training in method. But the art of being a pilgrim, if you will, is in the daily step by step movement. By the end of 40 days of walking, my body was so habituated that I naturally would get up every morning and begin walking.

And so it is with coaching – I am now about halfway through my Catholic Coaching Certification training. The drills are working their magic, but there are many miles to go on this journey. Still, I recognize the grace in listening to others and walking with them on our shared pilgrimage. I know that the path to God is made up of every small step we take. And that every small step adds up until we reach our final destination.

This summer, I walked my third Camino with my father – a short one, only about 75 miles.
I realized that walking with my dad was like coaching. He had a goal and destination that I shared. I knew a bit more about what lay ahead but was also walking a new path with him. I could help him look for the yellow arrows marking the path, but ultimately he had to take each step to bring himself closer and closer to our goal. He had his own pack to carry and his own mind to wrestle with. My job was to help him get on the right road and walk beside him.

Together, we walked in honor of my mother, and with the grace of God, the intercession of St. James, and the blessing of perfect weather, arrived in Santiago de Compostela on what would have been her 70th birthday.

Breaking Down “the Model,” Part 3: Action and Results

The Metanoia Catholic “Model” is the process we use to analyze our mindsets, bring them to the Lord, and find greater freedom. Here we’re going to talk about the last few steps of that model. If you missed the other parts, check out Part 1 and Part 2.

————————————————–

THE ACTION.

We previously talked about how emotions are the feelings that come from our thoughts. Now let’s take things one step further. Your emotions will either spur you to action or keep you from taking action. In other words, emotions will make you grow either in a virtue or in a vice.

The Catechism tells us that “A virtue is a habitual and firm disposition to do the good. It allows the person not only to perform good acts but to give the best of himself. The virtuous person tends toward the good with all his sensory and spiritual powers.” (CCC 1803)

Your thoughts and emotions affect whether you’re ordering your actions toward the good. That means growing in virtue starts with your thoughts and emotions! It also means that getting rid of vice also starts with your thoughts and emotions.

Of course, God gives you the grace to do that. And this is powerful knowledge to have for your spiritual life! When you see how your thoughts, emotions, and actions work together, it’s a game-changer. You’ll understand why you do the things you do, and you’ll know how to pray with God about it.

As an example, let’s continue the scenario from Part 2. Here’s the thought: You think you are stuck in a career and there’s nothing you can do about it. Here’s the emotion: You feel better or resentful toward your co-workers and employer. Now here’s the action: You treat your co-workers rudely and slack off in your work.

THE RESULTS.

Your actions have consequences. Not only do they affect the world around you, they affect your own interior life. Our negative thoughts in particular have a way of coming back to bite us.

For example, if you treat your co-workers badly and you slack off in your work, then of course you won’t get opportunities to advance in your career. So the thought that you are stuck in your job leads you into keeping yourself stuck.

See how a cycle like that can repeat itself? Circumstance, to thought, to emotion, to action, to result — which becomes the new circumstance. How do you break out of it?

The place to start is with your thoughts.

That’s why “The Model” is so useful. It shows us where we go astray (in our thoughts) and how changing our thoughts can change our lives for the better!

TO WRAP IT ALL UP…

When you recognize this pattern of how thoughts lead to actions, you can finally take charge of your interior life and start growing in the virtues that bring true joy and happiness. Most importantly, it opens you up to working with God to receive His graces and live the kind of life He wants for you.

This takes work, but it’s possible! Remember, you have God on your side. And we have some great resources here at Mentoia Catholic to help you too.

Want to learn more about the “Model” and what it can do for you? Check our podcast episode on The Model and its Roots in Aquinas!

Breaking down “The Model,” Part 1: Circumstances and Thoughts

The Metanoia Catholic “Model” is the process we use to analyze our mindsets, bring them to the Lord, and find greater freedom. Here we’re going to begin breaking down the first part of The Model on “circumstances and thoughts.” If you want to know more about our Model, check our podcast episode on The Model and its roots in Aquinas!

————————————————–

Have you ever felt powerless in your circumstances? Like, “if only there wasn’t this pandemic…” Or, “If only my kids were back in school…” Or, my favorite, “If only my spouse could be more patient…”

Then you’d feel better about your life, right?

But waiting for things to change is a terrible way to solve a problem—especially if the problem isn’t the circumstances you’re in, but the way you’re thinking about them.

Let us explain…

CIRCUMSTANCES.

Circumstances are objective truths, with no opinions attached, no interpretations, and no drama. Just facts. It’s the “trigger” or the object of the thoughts and feelings. The circumstance is data we take through our five senses before there is an interpretation attached to it.

Here’s an example: You might work for a company in a position that doesn’t challenge you and has left you feeling stuck, trapped, unfulfilled. The job is the circumstance you are in.

THOUGHTS.

Thoughts are our interpretations, judgments, opinions, perspectives, and stories about the specific circumstance. Thoughts are merely sentences in our brains about circumstances. They come from our prior experiences as well as the judgments of what we think is good or evil. Our thoughts are our subjective truth.

Here’s an example: Our thoughts about our job might lead us to think that we’re stuck in our career, that there’s nothing new we can learn, and no fulfillment or enjoyment we can gain from it.

It is important to distinguish between circumstances and thoughts because we often confuse our thoughts about a circumstance with the truth—and they are not the same thing.

Here’s what we mean: we get to choose our thoughts, but we don’t necessarily get to choose our circumstances. Oftentimes we think we have to change our circumstances to improve a situation. However, changing your circumstance should be the exception, not the rule.

Though we can’t always change our external circumstances, we always have the power to change our thoughts about our circumstances. Once we realize that, we can put our energy into changing what we can: ourselves! This both helps us grow and increases our peace.

Need an example? How about one from Scripture: “As they left the council, they rejoiced that they were considered worthy to suffer dishonor for the sake of the name” (Acts 5:41). Interpretation: the followers of Jesus had every right to be angry about being flogged for following Jesus—even hateful towards their oppressors—but instead, they chose to rejoice. It’s all about how we think of it.

Distinguishing between circumstances and thoughts also helps us to see the difference between objective truth and subjective truth. Objective truth is reality, facts, it is what is. Subjective truth is our personal interpretation of the world. The point of subjective truth is to lead us towards the highest objective truth—God.

© Copyright - Metanoia Catholic

Join our Next Free Live Come & See Open House. See if God is calling you to Catholic Coaching! Register Here

STORE                           CUSTOMER SUPPORT